Easy2Siksha.com
GNDU Question Paper-2024
B.A 3
rd
Semester
ECONOMICS
(Indian Economy)
Time Allowed: Three Hours Max. Marks:
Note: Attempt Five questions in all, selecting at least One question from each section. The
Fifth question may be attempted from any section. All questions carry equal marks
SECTION-A
1. Discuss various causes of decline in agricultural productivity in India.
2. Elaborate various clauses of WTO related with agriculture. How have they affected
Indian agriculture ?
SECTION-B
3. What are the major problems of Indian industry? How they can be solved?
4. Discuss the role of public sector in India. What are its major shortcomings?
SECTION-C
5. Critically examine various policy measures to promote foreign trade in India.
6. Why India faces adverse balance of payments? How it can be corrected?
Easy2Siksha.com
SECTION-D
7. Discuss the causes of inequality in India. How it can be removed?
8. Elaborate the main objectives of Indian Plans. How far have we been able to achieve
these objectives?
GNDU Answer Paper-2024
B.A 3
rd
Semester
ECONOMICS
(Indian Economy)
Time Allowed: Three Hours Max. Marks:
Note: Attempt Five questions in all, selecting at least One question from each section. The
Fifth question may be attempted from any section. All questions carry equal marks
SECTION-A
1. Discuss various causes of decline in agricultural productivity in India.
Ans: Causes of Decline in Agricultural Productivity in India
If you stand in a village field on a quiet morning, you’ll hear the sound of cows, the chatter
of farmers, and the rustle of crops swaying in the breeze. Agriculture has always been the
heart of India, feeding millions and providing livelihood to more than half of the population.
Yet, despite such importance, Indian agriculture has often struggled with low productivity.
The story of this struggle is not about one single problem—it is a mix of many causes, just
like the threads of a net. Let’s walk step by step into these causes and understand why
agricultural productivity has declined.
1. Dependence on Nature
Easy2Siksha.com
For centuries, Indian farmers have depended heavily on rainfall. Unlike countries where
irrigation systems cover almost all the fields, in India, even today, a large portion of farming
is rain-fed. When rains come on time, crops flourish. But when monsoons fail or arrive late,
farmers face droughts and crop failure. On the other hand, excessive rains or floods wash
away crops. This overdependence on nature makes productivity uncertain and low.
2. Small and Fragmented Land Holdings
Imagine trying to run a big factory inside a tiny room—you will struggle with space,
resources, and efficiency. The same happens in Indian agriculture. Over generations, as land
passes from parents to children, farms get divided into smaller and smaller pieces. Today,
many farmers own less than one hectare of land. These fragmented fields make it difficult to
use modern machinery, irrigation, or scientific techniques. As a result, productivity remains
low compared to countries where farms are larger and consolidated.
3. Traditional and Outdated Techniques
In many villages, you can still see farmers using bullocks and wooden ploughs. While
modern machinery like tractors, harvesters, and drip irrigation systems exist, not every
farmer can afford them. Poor farmers often rely on traditional methods that are less
efficient. These outdated tools may have worked centuries ago, but in today’s world, they
cannot meet the growing demand for food. Thus, productivity suffers.
4. Soil Degradation and Fertility Loss
The soil is like the heart of agriculture. But over the years, Indian soil has been overused and
poorly treated. Continuous cropping without giving the soil rest, excessive use of chemical
fertilizers, and lack of crop rotation have weakened the fertility of the land. In some areas,
over-irrigation has led to salinity and waterlogging, making fields unfit for cultivation. When
the soil loses its natural nutrients, productivity naturally falls.
5. Lack of Irrigation Facilities
While India has major rivers and dams, irrigation facilities do not reach every farmer. Only
about one-third of the total cultivated area is under assured irrigation. The rest depends on
rainfall. This means that in dry years, productivity drops drastically. Farmers who do not
have access to canals, tube wells, or modern irrigation methods are stuck in a cycle of
uncertainty.
Easy2Siksha.com
6. Shortage of Quality Seeds
Seeds are the starting point of farming—like the foundation of a building. If the foundation
is weak, the building cannot stand strong. Similarly, poor-quality seeds lead to low yields. In
India, many farmers still use old, unscientific, or even reused seeds, which give poor results.
Though research institutions have developed high-yielding and hybrid seeds, their
distribution and adoption are still limited in many rural areas.
7. Inadequate Use of Fertilizers and Manure
Balanced use of fertilizers and organic manure is essential for healthy crops. But in India, the
use of fertilizers is not only low compared to developed countries but also highly
unbalanced. For example, farmers often overuse nitrogen-based fertilizers while ignoring
phosphates and potash. This imbalance harms the soil and reduces long-term productivity.
Moreover, the use of cow dung and compost as manure has decreased because they are
often used as fuel instead of fertilizer.
8. Pests, Diseases, and Lack of Protection
Crops are living things, and just like humans, they too face diseases and attacks—from
pests, weeds, and insects. In India, many farmers do not have access to proper pesticides or
do not know how to use them effectively. This negligence leads to heavy crop losses every
year. Imagine a farmer working hard for months only to see half of his crop destroyed by
pests—it’s heartbreaking and a major reason for low productivity.
9. Low Capital Investment
Agriculture in India is often called a "gamble with the monsoon" because farmers lack the
money to invest in modern tools, machines, irrigation, or fertilizers. Most farmers are poor
and depend on moneylenders, who charge high interest. As a result, farmers cannot take
risks or improve their farms. Without proper investment, productivity remains stagnant.
10. Illiteracy and Lack of Awareness
Agriculture today is not just about sowing seeds—it requires scientific knowledge about soil
health, modern farming techniques, weather conditions, and pest management. But many
Indian farmers are illiterate or unaware of these modern practices. Even government
training programs and extension services do not always reach them effectively. This
knowledge gap keeps productivity low.
Easy2Siksha.com
11. Fragmented Agricultural Policies
While India has many agricultural policies, subsidies, and schemes, they are often poorly
implemented. Corruption, delay in providing benefits, and lack of coordination between
government agencies mean that farmers do not always get the help they need. For example,
subsidies on fertilizers or irrigation equipment may not reach the right people, leaving small
farmers behind.
12. Overdependence on Food Grains
Indian farmers mostly focus on food grains like wheat and rice because of government
procurement policies. This lack of crop diversification harms soil health and limits
opportunities for higher-value crops like fruits, vegetables, and pulses. As a result,
productivity per hectare remains low compared to diversified farming systems.
13. Climate Change
In recent years, climate change has added new challenges. Rising temperatures, irregular
rainfall, more frequent droughts and floods, and shifting seasons directly affect crops.
Farmers who once knew the rhythm of seasons now face uncertainty, leading to reduced
productivity.
14. Rural Poverty and Migration
Agriculture in India is not just about land and seeds—it also needs people. But rural poverty
often pushes young workers to migrate to cities for better opportunities. This leaves behind
an aging farming population that struggles with traditional methods and cannot adopt new
practices. With fewer hands on the field, productivity declines.
Conclusion
The decline in agricultural productivity in India is not the fault of one person or one factor—
it is a chain of interconnected problems. From small landholdings and outdated methods to
poor irrigation, soil degradation, and climate change, each problem adds a layer to the
challenge.
Yet, the story doesn’t end here. India has immense potential. With better irrigation facilities,
scientific farming, farmer education, soil care, and proper policies, productivity can rise
Easy2Siksha.com
again. The key lies in treating agriculture not as a gamble, but as a science combined with
care for nature.
So, when we look at India’s fields swaying in the wind, we must remember: behind every
grain of wheat or rice lies the hard work of a farmer—and the urgent need to support them
with resources, technology, and respect. Only then can agriculture truly bloom and
productivity rise.
2. Elaborate various clauses of WTO related with agriculture. How have they affected
Indian agriculture ?
Ans: WTO and Indian Agriculture: Clauses and Consequences
A Different Beginning
Imagine a farmer in Punjab in the mid-1990s. He grows wheat and rice, sells them in the
local mandi, and depends on government support prices to make ends meet. Suddenly, the
world around him changes. India joins the World Trade Organization (WTO) in 1995, and
with it comes a new set of rules about how countries can trade, subsidize, and protect their
farmers.
At first, it sounds promising: Indian basmati rice, mangoes, and spices could reach global
markets more easily. But soon, the farmer realizes that these rules are a double-edged
sword. While they open doors, they also bring competition, restrictions, and challenges.
To understand this, let’s first look at the clauses of the WTO Agreement on Agriculture
(AoA).
Clauses of WTO Related to Agriculture
The Agreement on Agriculture (AoA), signed during the Uruguay Round of GATT
negotiations and enforced in 1995, rests on three main pillars:
1. Market Access
• Countries had to reduce tariffs (import duties) and remove non-tariff barriers (like
quotas and bans) on agricultural products.
• Developed countries agreed to cut tariffs by 36% over six years, while developing
countries like India had to cut them by 24% over ten years.
• This meant India had to open its markets to foreign agricultural products.
Impact: Indian farmers now faced competition from cheap imports, especially from
countries where farmers were heavily subsidized.
2. Domestic Support (Subsidies)
Easy2Siksha.com
• The AoA classified subsidies into “boxes”:
o Amber Box: Trade-distorting subsidies (like price support). These had to be
reduced.
o Blue Box: Subsidies linked to production-limiting programs (allowed).
o Green Box: Non-trade-distorting subsidies (like research, environmental
programs, food security)—these were permitted without limits.
• Developing countries like India were allowed a subsidy up to 10% of the value of
agricultural production (de minimis level).
Impact: India’s Minimum Support Price (MSP) and input subsidies (like fertilizer and
electricity) came under scrutiny. Developed countries accused India of breaching limits,
even though their own subsidies were much higher but cleverly placed in the “Green Box.”
3. Export Subsidies
• Countries had to reduce subsidies that encouraged exports of agricultural products.
• Developed countries agreed to cut the value of export subsidies by 36% and the
quantity of subsidized exports by 21% over six years.
• Developing countries had to cut them by 24% and 14% respectively over ten years.
Impact: India, which did not provide large export subsidies, was less affected here. But
Indian exporters still struggled because developed countries continued to support their
farmers indirectly, making their products cheaper in global markets.
4. Sanitary and Phytosanitary (SPS) Measures
• WTO also allowed countries to set standards for food safety and animal/plant health.
• While meant to protect consumers, these standards often became barriers to trade.
Impact: Indian exports like mangoes, grapes, and spices often faced rejection in foreign
markets due to strict SPS standards, even when quality was good.
Impact of WTO Clauses on Indian Agriculture
Now let’s see how these clauses played out in real life for Indian agriculture.
1. Increased Competition
• With reduced tariffs, India had to allow imports of edible oils, dairy products, and
pulses.
• Cheap imports, especially palm oil from Southeast Asia, flooded the market, hurting
Indian oilseed farmers.
• Similarly, Indian dairy farmers faced pressure from subsidized milk products from
Europe.
2. Pressure on Subsidies
Easy2Siksha.com
• India’s MSP system and input subsidies came under global scrutiny.
• Developed countries argued that India was distorting trade by giving high subsidies.
• But the irony was that the US and EU gave far higher subsidies to their farmers,
cleverly categorized under “Green Box.”
• This created an unequal playing field: Indian farmers, with small landholdings and
limited resources, had to compete with heavily subsidized Western farmers.
3. Export Opportunities and Challenges
• On the positive side, WTO rules opened global markets for Indian products like
basmati rice, cotton, tea, and spices.
• India became a major exporter of rice and cotton.
• However, strict quality standards and subsidies in developed countries limited India’s
competitiveness.
• For example, Indian cotton farmers struggled because US cotton farmers received
billions in subsidies, lowering global prices.
4. Food Security Concerns
• India runs massive food security programs like the Public Distribution System (PDS)
and the National Food Security Act (2013).
• These involve buying food grains at MSP and distributing them at subsidized rates.
• WTO members, especially the US, argued that India’s food stockpiling programs
violated subsidy limits.
• India fought hard at WTO negotiations to protect its right to support poor farmers
and ensure food security.
5. Sanitary Barriers
• Indian exports often faced rejection due to SPS measures.
• For example, Indian mangoes were banned in the EU for a period due to fruit fly
concerns.
• This hurt farmers and exporters, showing how “standards” could be used as hidden
trade barriers.
6. Shift in Cropping Patterns
• With global demand influencing prices, Indian farmers began shifting towards
export-oriented crops like cotton, basmati rice, and sugarcane.
• While this brought profits for some, it also increased risks—global price fluctuations
often left farmers in debt.
Critical Evaluation
The WTO’s agricultural clauses were meant to create a fair global trading system. But in
practice, they often favored developed countries.
• For India:
Easy2Siksha.com
o Opportunities: Access to global markets, rise in exports of rice, cotton, and
spices.
o Challenges: Cheap imports, pressure on subsidies, strict standards, and
unequal competition.
• The Irony:
o Developed countries continued to support their farmers massively, while
asking developing countries to cut support.
o This created a system where Indian farmers, who are mostly small and
marginal, were at a disadvantage.
Conclusion
The story of WTO and Indian agriculture is like a tug-of-war. On one side, there is the
promise of global markets, higher exports, and modernization. On the other side, there is
the reality of cheap imports, subsidy disputes, and vulnerable farmers.
The clauses of the WTO Agreement on Agriculture—Market Access, Domestic Support,
Export Subsidies, and SPS measures—have reshaped Indian agriculture in both positive and
negative ways.
For students, the key is to remember:
• Clauses: Market Access, Domestic Support, Export Subsidies, SPS measures.
• Impact: Competition from imports, pressure on subsidies, export opportunities with
challenges, food security concerns, and shifting cropping patterns.
Explained as a story, WTO is not just about trade rules—it is about the everyday life of an
Indian farmer, whose fate is tied not only to the monsoon but also to decisions made in
Geneva.
SECTION-B
3. What are the major problems of Indian industry? How they can be solved?
Ans: A Different Beginning
Imagine you are walking through an Indian marketplace. On one side, you see stalls selling
colorful textiles, spices, and handicrafts made by small-scale artisans. On the other side, you
notice factories in the distance with smoke rising from chimneys. India’s industry is like this
marketplace—full of energy, variety, and potential. But just as the market has its noise,
crowd, and confusion, Indian industries also face many hurdles that stop them from
reaching their full potential.
Now, let us take a journey through the world of Indian industry—first to understand its
major problems and then to see how these problems can be solved.
Easy2Siksha.com
The Major Problems of Indian Industry
Like a person who grows but faces obstacles along the way, India’s industries too struggle
with several challenges. Let’s unfold them one by one in a simple and humanized way.
1. Lack of Modern Technology
Think of an old sewing machine compared to a brand-new automatic one. The old one
works but is slow and less efficient. Similarly, many Indian industries still depend on
outdated machinery and methods. This reduces productivity and increases costs. In global
competition, this becomes a major drawback.
2. Shortage of Skilled Labor
India has a huge population, but not everyone has the right training for industrial jobs. It’s
like having a cricket team where players love the game but don’t know proper techniques.
Industries often complain that while people are available, skilled workers are missing.
3. Energy Crisis
Industries need power like humans need food. But India often suffers from electricity
shortages, high energy costs, and irregular supply. Imagine running a bakery where ovens
stop working every few hours—you simply cannot bake enough bread. This is what
industries face when electricity fails them.
4. Poor Infrastructure
Roads full of potholes, congested ports, and slow railway networks—these are real
problems. If raw materials cannot reach factories on time and finished goods cannot reach
markets quickly, industries suffer delays and losses. Infrastructure becomes like a weak
backbone, unable to carry the weight of growth.
5. Financial Problems
For industries, money is like oxygen. But many small and medium industries in India struggle
to get enough finance from banks or investors. Loans are often hard to get, interest rates
Easy2Siksha.com
are high, and sometimes corruption makes it worse. This leaves industries gasping for
survival.
6. Government Policies and Red Tape
Industries often complain about too many rules and paperwork. For every small approval,
they need to run from one office to another. This “license raj” mindset, though reduced, still
exists. It’s like asking a runner to tie their legs with ropes and then expecting them to win a
race.
7. Stiff Competition
Indian industries face competition not only from within the country but also from
international giants. Cheap Chinese products, for example, flood Indian markets, making it
difficult for local industries to survive. Imagine a small shopkeeper trying to compete with a
giant supermarket—it’s tough.
8. Regional Imbalances
Industries in India are not equally spread. Some states like Maharashtra, Gujarat, and Tamil
Nadu are highly industrialized, while others lag far behind. This creates unequal growth and
migration problems, as workers leave their home states in search of jobs.
9. Environmental Concerns
Industries often pollute rivers, air, and soil. While industries bring jobs and income, they
sometimes harm health and the environment. This becomes a balancing act—development
vs. sustainability.
10. Low Productivity and Poor Quality
Indian products are sometimes criticized for being less durable or not meeting international
standards. In today’s world, where quality matters more than quantity, this becomes a
roadblock to exports.
11. Industrial Sickness
Easy2Siksha.com
Many industries, especially small-scale ones, close down within a few years. Reasons include
mismanagement, lack of finance, and inability to adapt. It’s like planting a tree that cannot
grow strong roots—it withers away.
12. Social and Political Issues
Strikes, lockouts, and political interference also harm industries. Workers and management
often fail to cooperate, leading to disputes. Instead of rowing the boat together, they row in
opposite directions, and the boat goes nowhere.
How Can These Problems Be Solved?
Every problem has a solution if we look closely. Let’s now explore how these hurdles can be
overcome.
1. Adopting Modern Technology
Industries should invest in research, innovation, and modern machines. Government
support in the form of tax benefits for technology upgrades can help. Imagine upgrading
from a bicycle to a motorcycle—you can cover more distance in less time.
2. Skill Development
India needs more vocational training centers, industrial training institutes (ITIs), and
practical-based education. If workers are trained well, industries will not face a shortage of
skilled manpower. This is like training young cricketers in academies before sending them to
international matches.
3. Improving Power Supply
Focus on renewable energy like solar, wind, and hydro power can reduce dependency on
coal and oil. Better management of electricity distribution will also ensure industries get
uninterrupted supply.
4. Developing Infrastructure
Easy2Siksha.com
Investments in better roads, faster railways, smart ports, and efficient logistics will make
industries more competitive. When the roads are smooth, the journey of industrial growth
also becomes smooth.
5. Easy Access to Finance
Banks and financial institutions should provide low-interest loans and flexible repayment
policies. The government can also set up special funds for small and medium industries. This
is like giving oxygen cylinders to those who are struggling to breathe.
6. Simplifying Rules
Instead of endless paperwork, industries should have single-window clearances. Digital
platforms can reduce corruption and delays. This way, entrepreneurs can focus on
innovation rather than on running from office to office.
7. Promoting Exports and Fair Competition
Indian products should be promoted globally with proper branding. At the same time,
safeguards against cheap foreign imports should be implemented to protect local industries.
8. Balanced Regional Growth
The government should encourage industries to set up factories in backward states by giving
tax holidays, subsidies, and better facilities. This will reduce migration and promote
balanced growth.
9. Eco-Friendly Practices
Industries should adopt pollution control technologies and focus on green manufacturing.
Government should enforce strict laws while also rewarding industries that maintain
sustainability.
10. Focusing on Quality
Easy2Siksha.com
Industries should set high quality standards and adopt international certifications. When
Indian products are known for reliability, exports will automatically grow.
11. Reviving Sick Industries
Special rehabilitation packages, better management training, and modern technology can
help revive industries on the verge of closure.
12. Promoting Industrial Harmony
Regular dialogue between workers and employers, along with fair wages and safe working
conditions, can reduce strikes and disputes. If everyone rows the boat in the same direction,
industries will surely move forward.
Conclusion
The story of Indian industry is like a young student with extraordinary potential but
struggling with challenges—lack of books, poor classrooms, and limited guidance. If we
provide the right environment, resources, and motivation, the student can top the class.
Similarly, if India solves problems like outdated technology, lack of skilled labor, energy
crisis, financial hurdles, and poor infrastructure, our industries can shine globally. The
solutions are not impossible; they just require strong willpower, cooperation between
government and industry, and active participation of society.
In short, India’s industrial sector is a powerful engine of growth. Once we clear the obstacles
from its path, it can drive the country towards prosperity, employment, and global
recognition.
4. Discuss the role of public sector in India. What are its major shortcomings?
Ans: The Role of Public Sector in India and Its Shortcomings
A Different Beginning
Imagine India in 1947. The country had just won independence, but it was like a house with
broken walls and empty rooms. Industries were few, infrastructure was weak, poverty was
widespread, and private capital was scarce. The new nation needed a builder—someone
who could lay the foundation of growth, provide jobs, and ensure that wealth was not
concentrated in a few hands.
Easy2Siksha.com
That builder was the public sector. Owned and managed by the government, public sector
enterprises became the engines of development in the early decades of independent India.
They were not just businesses; they were symbols of self-reliance, national pride, and social
justice.
The Role of the Public Sector in India
1. Laying the Industrial Foundation
• After independence, India lacked a strong industrial base.
• The public sector stepped in to build heavy industries like steel, coal, power, and
machinery.
• Giants like Bhilai Steel Plant, BHEL, ONGC, and NTPC were created to provide the
backbone of industrialization.
• These were industries where private players were unwilling or unable to invest due
to high costs and long gestation periods.
Without the public sector, India could not have built the basic infrastructure needed for
growth.
2. Promoting Balanced Regional Development
• Private industries preferred big cities and profitable regions.
• The government used public sector enterprises to set up industries in backward
areas, creating jobs and reducing regional imbalances.
• For example, steel plants were set up in places like Bhilai (Chhattisgarh), Rourkela
(Odisha), and Durgapur (West Bengal), which were not industrial hubs earlier.
The public sector became a tool for spreading development across the map of India.
3. Generating Employment
• Public sector enterprises became major employers, providing secure jobs to millions.
• They absorbed not only skilled workers but also semi-skilled and unskilled labour.
• In a country struggling with unemployment, this was a lifeline.
4. Ensuring Social Justice
• The public sector was not driven by profit alone—it had a social mission.
• It provided affordable goods and services, from electricity to transport.
• It also implemented policies of reservation, giving opportunities to marginalized
groups.
In this way, the public sector became a vehicle for equity, not just efficiency.
5. Mobilizing Resources for Development
Easy2Siksha.com
• Public sector enterprises generated revenue for the government through dividends,
taxes, and profits.
• These resources were used for welfare schemes, education, health, and rural
development.
6. Strategic and National Security Role
• Sectors like defense production, atomic energy, and petroleum were kept under
public ownership for security reasons.
• Enterprises like HAL (Hindustan Aeronautics Limited) and DRDO played a crucial role
in strengthening India’s defense capabilities.
7. Providing Essential Services
• Public sector undertakings like Indian Railways, BSNL, and LIC provided essential
services at affordable rates.
• They ensured that even remote areas had access to transport, communication, and
insurance.
8. Countering Private Monopoly
• In the early years, the public sector prevented concentration of wealth in a few
hands.
• By controlling key industries, it ensured that private monopolies did not dominate
the economy.
Major Shortcomings of the Public Sector
But as the decades passed, the story of the public sector also revealed its flaws. The builder
who once laid the foundation began to stumble under its own weight.
1. Low Efficiency and Productivity
• Many public sector enterprises became overstaffed and inefficient.
• Lack of competition led to complacency.
• Productivity was often low compared to private sector counterparts.
For example, while Indian Railways is vast, it has often been criticized for inefficiency
and delays.
2. Political Interference
• Appointments and decisions were often influenced by politics rather than merit.
• This led to corruption, favoritism, and poor management.
3. Financial Losses
Easy2Siksha.com
• Many PSUs (Public Sector Undertakings) ran into heavy losses due to
mismanagement, outdated technology, and lack of innovation.
• Instead of generating revenue, they became a burden on the government
exchequer.
• Examples include Air India (before privatization) and several state electricity boards.
4. Lack of Innovation and Modernization
• Public sector enterprises often failed to keep up with technological changes.
• Bureaucratic procedures slowed down decision-making.
• As a result, they lost competitiveness in global markets.
5. Overstaffing and Low Accountability
• Jobs in the public sector were seen as secure, leading to a lack of motivation among
employees.
• Overstaffing increased costs without improving output.
• Accountability was weak, as losses were covered by government bailouts.
6. Regional and Sectoral Imbalances
• While the public sector did promote regional development, it could not fully
eliminate imbalances.
• Some regions still remained neglected, and some sectors were overemphasized
while others lagged.
7. Burden on Taxpayers
• Loss-making PSUs had to be supported by government funds.
• This diverted resources away from health, education, and welfare.
8. Resistance to Change
• Trade unions in public sector enterprises often resisted reforms, privatization, or
modernization.
• This made restructuring difficult.
Reforms and the Way Forward
Recognizing these shortcomings, India began liberalizing its economy in 1991. The role of
the public sector was redefined:
• Privatization: Loss-making PSUs were sold or disinvested.
• Public-Private Partnerships (PPP): Infrastructure projects began involving private
players.
• Focus on Core Areas: The public sector was asked to concentrate on strategic
industries like defense, energy, and infrastructure.
Easy2Siksha.com
Today, the public sector still plays a vital role, but it is no longer the sole driver of growth.
The private sector has emerged as a strong partner, while the government focuses on
regulation, welfare, and strategic industries.
Conclusion
The story of the public sector in India is like that of a parent who raised a child. In the early
years, it provided everything—food, shelter, education. But as the child (the economy)
grew, the parent’s role had to change. The public sector built the foundation of modern
India: industries, infrastructure, jobs, and social justice. But over time, inefficiency, losses,
and political interference exposed its weaknesses.
SECTION-C
5. Critically examine various policy measures to promote foreign trade in India.
Ans: A Story-like Beginning
Imagine India as a young traveler setting out on a long journey in the world market. In the
early days, this traveler was shy and protective, holding tight to its own resources, not
letting others interfere. But as time passed, India realized that to grow stronger, it must
interact, exchange, and build relationships with the rest of the world.
This realization gave rise to policies — rules, reforms, and strategies — that acted like
guiding lamps for India’s journey in foreign trade. But just like any story, there were
successes, failures, and lessons learned. Let us walk step by step through these policies,
their achievements, and their shortcomings.
What is Foreign Trade and Why Does it Matter?
Foreign trade simply means the buying and selling of goods and services between countries.
For India, foreign trade is like opening the window of a house to let fresh air in — it brings in
advanced technology, investment, and new opportunities, while also allowing Indian
products like textiles, spices, IT services, and pharmaceuticals to reach global markets.
But to make this trade smooth and beneficial, policies are needed — like road signs guiding
traffic. India has framed many such measures over time, and now we will critically examine
them.
1. Import Substitution Policy (1950s–1970s)
Easy2Siksha.com
When India became independent, it was economically weak and dependent on foreign
goods. The leaders felt, “If we keep importing everything, how will our industries grow?” So,
the government adopted the Import Substitution Industrialization (ISI) policy.
• What it meant: Focus on producing goods within India instead of importing them.
• Measures: High import tariffs, strict quotas, and licensing system.
• Success: Helped India build a foundation of industries like steel, chemicals, and
machinery.
• Failure: Created a “license raj,” where businesses needed too many approvals. Also,
quality suffered because Indian producers faced no foreign competition.
Critical view: While it protected infant industries, it also made Indian products less
competitive in global markets.
2. Export Promotion Policy (1970s onwards)
By the 1970s, India realized it could not survive by producing only for itself. It needed
foreign exchange to import oil, technology, and machinery. Hence, a shift was made toward
export promotion.
• Measures Taken:
o Establishment of Export Promotion Councils.
o Special incentives like duty drawbacks, tax exemptions, and subsidies for
exporters.
o Development of Free Trade Zones (later Special Economic Zones).
• Success: India’s exports of textiles, gems, and handicrafts began to rise.
• Failure: Still, export growth was slow because bureaucracy and poor infrastructure
acted like roadblocks.
Critical view: A good step forward, but policies remained half-hearted until liberalization in
the 1990s.
3. Liberalization, Privatization, Globalization (1991 Reforms)
This was the turning point in India’s trade story. By 1991, India faced a severe balance of
payment crisis — the country barely had foreign reserves for two weeks of imports. This
crisis forced the government to open the doors wide to the world.
• Measures:
o Removal of many import restrictions.
o Reduction of tariffs and duties.
o Abolition of industrial licensing in many sectors.
o Encouragement of Foreign Direct Investment (FDI).
o Rupee devaluation to make exports more attractive.
Easy2Siksha.com
• Success: India’s exports and imports grew rapidly. IT services became global. Foreign
companies invested heavily in Indian industries.
• Failure: Greater dependence on imports, especially crude oil, led to vulnerability.
Also, some domestic industries, like small-scale units, struggled against international
giants.
Critical view: This policy gave India global recognition, but it also increased inequality and
made the country dependent on external markets.
4. Foreign Trade Policy (2004–2009, 2009–2014, etc.)
India started announcing Foreign Trade Policies (FTP) every five years to give clear
directions.
• Key Features:
o Duty-free import of raw materials for exporters.
o Special incentives for labor-intensive sectors like textiles and handicrafts.
o Focus on SEZs (Special Economic Zones) to attract investment.
o Market Access Initiative Scheme to explore new markets.
• Success: Helped exporters gain competitiveness. SEZs became hubs of foreign trade.
• Failure: Implementation was uneven, and global recessions (like 2008) hurt exports
badly.
Critical view: Policies were ambitious but often over-dependent on global conditions.
5. “Make in India” and Other Recent Initiatives
In recent years, India has promoted foreign trade by linking it with domestic industrial
growth.
• Make in India (2014): Encouraged manufacturing in India with the goal of making
the country a global hub.
• Digital India & Start-up India: Promoted IT services and innovation for global
markets.
• Production Linked Incentive (PLI) Scheme: Offered financial incentives to industries
(like electronics, pharma, textiles) to boost production and exports.
• Trade Agreements: India signed and negotiated Free Trade Agreements (FTAs) with
countries like Japan, UAE, and ASEAN to reduce trade barriers.
• Success: India became a strong exporter of software services, generic medicines, and
mobile phones.
• Failure: Trade deficit (imports > exports) remains a big challenge, especially due to
heavy imports of crude oil, gold, and electronics.
Easy2Siksha.com
Critical view: These policies improved India’s image but still could not balance the trade
gap.
6. Role of WTO and Global Trade Rules
India’s trade policies are also shaped by global institutions like the World Trade Organization
(WTO).
• Advantages: Helped India access global markets under fair rules.
• Problems: Often, developed countries push their agenda, making it tough for
developing countries like India. For example, strict rules on agriculture subsidies limit
India’s support to its farmers.
Critical view: WTO ensures participation but reduces India’s policy freedom.
Major Achievements of India’s Trade Policies
1. Diversification of exports (not just raw materials, but IT services, pharma,
automobiles).
2. Integration with the global economy.
3. Increased foreign exchange reserves.
4. Growth of modern sectors like IT and biotechnology.
Challenges and Criticism
1. Trade Deficit: Imports are consistently higher than exports.
2. Dependence on Crude Oil: Affects stability of trade.
3. Infrastructure Gaps: Ports, transport, and logistics remain weaker compared to
China or developed nations.
4. Global Uncertainties: Recession, pandemics, and wars often disrupt India’s trade
targets.
5. Domestic Inequality: Benefits of foreign trade are not equally shared — urban and
tech-savvy sectors benefit more than farmers and small-scale industries.
Conclusion: The Road Ahead
So, India’s foreign trade policies can be seen as the different stages of a traveler’s journey —
from cautious protection in the early years to confident globalization in the 1990s, and now,
to a mix of self-reliance and global integration.
Easy2Siksha.com
Critically speaking, these policies have brought India far ahead, but they have also exposed
weaknesses like trade deficits and over-dependence on imports. The road ahead lies in
balancing global opportunities with domestic strength — by building world-class
infrastructure, supporting small industries, negotiating fair trade deals, and ensuring that
trade benefits reach the grassroots.
6. Why India faces adverse balance of payments? How it can be corrected?
Ans: India’s Adverse Balance of Payments: Causes and Corrections
A Different Beginning
Imagine a family that earns a decent income every month. But this family has big dreams:
they want to build a new house, buy a car, send their children abroad for studies, and also
host lavish parties. Their income is steady, but their expenses keep rising faster. To cover
the gap, they borrow from relatives and banks. For a while, things look fine, but soon the
debts pile up, and the family realizes they are living beyond their means.
This is exactly what happens with a country’s Balance of Payments. The BoP is like the
nation’s financial diary, recording all transactions with the rest of the world—exports,
imports, loans, investments, remittances. When imports and outflows exceed exports and
inflows, the diary shows a deficit. India, despite its strengths, has often faced an adverse
balance of payments. Let’s explore why.
Why India Faces Adverse Balance of Payments
1. High Import Dependence
• India imports huge quantities of crude oil, which alone accounts for more than 25%
of its import bill.
• Gold is another major import, driven by cultural demand.
• Machinery, electronics, and defense equipment also add to the bill.
• These essential imports often outpace export earnings.
It’s like a family spending most of its income on fuel and jewelry, leaving little for
savings.
2. Slow Growth of Exports
• India’s exports have grown, but not as fast as imports.
• Traditional exports like textiles, tea, and jute lost ground due to global competition.
• Even in modern sectors like IT and pharmaceuticals, growth is uneven.
• Quality issues, high logistics costs, and lack of branding reduce competitiveness.
It’s like running a shop where sales grow slowly, but expenses shoot up every year.
Easy2Siksha.com
3. Oil Price Shocks
• Whenever global crude oil prices rise, India’s import bill balloons.
• The oil shocks of the 1970s, 1990s, and even recent years have worsened the BoP
situation.
Imagine your household budget suddenly collapsing because petrol prices doubled
overnight.
4. Rising External Debt and Interest Payments
• India borrows from international institutions and foreign investors to finance
deficits.
• Repaying loans and interest adds to outflows, worsening the BoP.
5. Trade Deficits with Key Partners
• India imports more from countries like China than it exports to them.
• This creates persistent bilateral trade deficits.
6. Global Factors
• Recession in global markets reduces demand for Indian exports.
• Protectionist policies in developed countries create barriers.
• Currency fluctuations make exports less competitive.
7. Domestic Inflation
• Higher domestic prices make Indian goods costlier abroad.
• This reduces export competitiveness and encourages imports.
8. Expenditure on Defense and Technology
• India spends heavily on importing defense equipment, advanced machinery, and
technology.
• These are necessary but add to the deficit.
9. Cultural Import Habits
• Indians have a strong appetite for foreign goods—luxury cars, electronics, branded
clothing.
• This consumer preference increases imports unnecessarily.
How Can It Be Corrected?
Now, let’s see how India can balance its books and move from deficit to stability.
1. Boosting Exports
Easy2Siksha.com
• Diversify exports beyond traditional goods.
• Focus on high-value sectors like electronics, engineering, IT, biotechnology, and
green technology.
• Improve branding of Indian products globally.
• Negotiate better trade agreements to open new markets.
If the family shop sells more variety and better-quality goods, income will rise.
2. Reducing Import Dependence
• Promote renewable energy to cut oil imports.
• Encourage domestic production of electronics, defense equipment, and fertilizers.
• Launch campaigns to reduce unnecessary gold imports by promoting financial
savings alternatives.
If the family learns to cook at home instead of eating out daily, expenses will fall.
3. Improving Infrastructure and Logistics
• Reduce transport costs by modernizing ports, roads, and railways.
• Lower logistics costs will make exports more competitive.
4. Encouraging Foreign Investment
• Attract more Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) in manufacturing and services.
• Stable policies and ease of doing business can bring in long-term capital inflows.
5. Promoting Tourism and Services
• Tourism, education, and healthcare can earn valuable foreign exchange.
• India’s IT sector should expand into new markets and services.
6. Exchange Rate Management
• Allowing the rupee to depreciate moderately can make exports cheaper and imports
costlier, improving the trade balance.
7. Import Substitution and Atmanirbhar Bharat
• Encourage domestic industries to produce goods that are heavily imported.
• The Production Linked Incentive (PLI) schemes are steps in this direction.
8. Agricultural Exports
• India has huge potential in agricultural exports—spices, rice, fruits, vegetables.
• By improving storage, processing, and quality standards, India can capture global
markets.
Easy2Siksha.com
9. Debt Management
• Borrow cautiously and focus on concessional loans.
• Reduce dependence on short-term external debt.
10. Public Awareness and Consumption Patterns
• Encourage citizens to prefer domestic products.
• Campaigns like “Vocal for Local” can reduce unnecessary imports.
Critical View
• Correcting BoP is not about stopping imports altogether—many imports like oil and
technology are essential for growth.
• The real solution lies in export promotion, import rationalization, and efficient use
of foreign capital.
• India must balance self-reliance with global integration, ensuring that policies don’t
slip into protectionism.
Conclusion
India’s adverse balance of payments is like a household budget stretched too thin—too
many expenses, not enough income. The causes are clear: high import dependence
(especially oil and gold), slow export growth, global shocks, debt repayments, and consumer
preferences.
The corrections are also clear: boost exports, reduce unnecessary imports, attract
investment, manage debt wisely, and build competitiveness.
For students, the key is to remember:
• Causes: Import dependence, weak exports, oil shocks, debt, inflation, global factors.
• Corrections: Export promotion, import substitution, FDI, tourism, exchange rate
management, infrastructure, and awareness.
Explained as a story, India’s BoP is not just about numbers—it is about how a nation
manages its income and expenses in the global marketplace. With the right balance, India
can turn deficits into surpluses and stride confidently on the path of sustainable growth.
Easy2Siksha.com
SECTION-D
7. Discuss the causes of inequality in India. How it can be removed?
Ans: Causes of Inequality in India and Its Removal
Imagine India as a huge family sitting around a dining table. On this table, there is plenty of
food, but strangely, some members have plates overflowing with delicious dishes, while
others have only crumbs or nothing at all. This picture is a simple way to understand
inequality — a situation where some people enjoy far more wealth, opportunities, and
resources, while others are left struggling for even the basics.
Inequality is not something that appeared suddenly; it has grown over centuries due to
various historical, social, and economic reasons. To understand it better, let us walk step by
step through the main causes of inequality in India, and then explore how it can be removed
so that everyone sitting around the “Indian dining table” can eat with dignity.
Causes of Inequality in India
1. Historical Legacy
India’s past plays a major role in shaping its present inequality. During colonial rule, the
British drained wealth from India, leaving behind poverty, illiteracy, and underdevelopment.
Large zamindari systems kept land in the hands of a few landlords, while peasants struggled
as laborers. Even after independence, the effects of this history linger — wealth and
resources remain unevenly distributed.
2. Caste System and Social Discrimination
One of the deepest roots of inequality in India is the caste system. For centuries, society was
divided into rigid hierarchies where certain groups were privileged, and others were denied
even basic rights. Though caste-based discrimination is legally banned today, its shadow still
exists in many villages and towns, affecting access to education, jobs, and social respect.
3. Unequal Access to Education
Education is like a key that opens the door to opportunities. But not everyone in India gets
this key. Children in rich urban families study in private schools with modern facilities, while
children in poor rural families often struggle in schools with few teachers, poor
infrastructure, and lack of resources. This difference creates a cycle: educated children
become successful adults, while uneducated ones remain trapped in poverty.
4. Poverty and Unemployment
Easy2Siksha.com
Another major cause of inequality is widespread poverty and unemployment. In rural areas,
many people depend on agriculture, but land is often small and income is uncertain. In
cities, millions migrate in search of jobs but end up working in low-paid, unorganized
sectors. This keeps the rich richer and the poor stuck where they are.
5. Gender Inequality
Inequality is not just about money; it is also about opportunities between men and women.
In many parts of India, women face restrictions in education, work, and decision-making.
They are often paid less than men for the same work and are underrepresented in politics
and leadership positions. This gender gap adds another layer to inequality.
6. Regional Imbalance
India is a land of contrasts. Some states like Maharashtra, Gujarat, Tamil Nadu, and
Karnataka are economically strong, with industries and modern infrastructure. Others, like
Bihar, Odisha, and some Northeastern states, lag behind in development. This uneven
growth creates regional inequality, where opportunities are not the same everywhere.
7. Corruption and Poor Governance
When resources meant for the poor are misused by corrupt officials or politicians, inequality
widens. Funds for education, healthcare, and rural development sometimes fail to reach
those in need, making the gap between rich and poor even bigger.
8. Globalization and Technology Divide
Globalization has created new opportunities but mostly for those who are educated and
skilled. Urban professionals in IT, finance, and business have benefited greatly, but unskilled
workers and rural populations often feel left out. Similarly, the digital divide (lack of access
to the internet and technology) makes it harder for the poor to compete in the modern
economy.
How Inequality Can Be Removed
Now that we know why inequality exists, let us see how it can be reduced. Returning to our
dining table story — how can we ensure that everyone has a fair share of food, not just a
few?
1. Quality Education for All
The most powerful weapon against inequality is education. If every child in India, whether in
a village or city, can get free, quality education with good teachers and facilities, the cycle of
poverty can be broken. Schemes like mid-day meals, scholarships, and digital classrooms can
help bridge the education gap.
Easy2Siksha.com
2. Employment Generation
The government and private sector must work together to create more jobs, especially in
rural areas. Skill development programs can train youth for modern industries. Small
businesses and start-ups should be encouraged with loans and support, so people don’t
have to depend only on agriculture or low-paid labor.
3. Land and Agrarian Reforms
Equitable distribution of land and better support for farmers can reduce rural inequality.
Ensuring fair prices for crops, modern farming techniques, and access to credit can improve
farmers’ lives and reduce poverty in villages.
4. Empowering Women
True equality cannot be achieved unless women are empowered. This means giving them
equal access to education, employment, and leadership roles. Strict enforcement of laws
against dowry, child marriage, and workplace discrimination is necessary. When women
rise, families and communities rise with them.
5. Bridging Regional Gaps
Special attention should be given to backward states and regions. Building better roads,
schools, hospitals, and industries in underdeveloped areas can reduce migration and
balance growth. The idea should be “Sabka Saath, Sabka Vikas” — development for all, not
just for a few states or cities.
6. Social Equality and Awareness
Laws alone cannot remove inequality. Society itself must change its mindset. Discrimination
based on caste, religion, or gender must end. Campaigns promoting equality and unity
should be encouraged, so that every Indian feels valued and respected.
7. Good Governance and Anti-Corruption Measures
Funds meant for development must reach the people without leakage. Transparency,
accountability, and honest governance can ensure that schemes for the poor actually
benefit them. Technology like direct benefit transfer (DBT) has already helped reduce
corruption in welfare schemes.
8. Bridging the Digital Divide
In today’s world, the internet is as important as electricity or water. Providing affordable
internet, mobile connectivity, and digital training to rural areas can open doors of
opportunity for millions who are otherwise left behind.
Easy2Siksha.com
Conclusion
Inequality in India is like a wound that has been growing for centuries. It is caused by
history, caste, poverty, gender discrimination, unemployment, and many other factors. But
just because it is old and deep does not mean it cannot be healed. By giving everyone equal
opportunities in education, jobs, healthcare, and social life, India can move towards a more
just and balanced society.
Imagine again the big Indian family at the dining table. When every member has enough
food on their plate — not too much, not too little — the whole family feels happy and
united. That is exactly what India needs: fairness, dignity, and equality for all.
8. Elaborate the main objectives of Indian Plans. How far have we been able to achieve
these objectives?
Ans: Objectives of Indian Plans and Their Achievements
A Different Beginning
Picture India in 1951. The wounds of Partition were fresh, poverty was widespread,
industries were scarce, and agriculture was fragile. The leaders of independent India knew
that freedom alone was not enough—what the country needed was a roadmap for growth.
So, like a family sitting together to plan its monthly budget, India sat down to plan its future.
The Planning Commission was set up in 1950, and the first Five-Year Plan was launched in
1951. From then until 2017, India prepared 12 such Plans, each with its own priorities but
guided by a set of broad objectives.
Main Objectives of Indian Plans
Though each Plan had its own focus, the overall objectives of Indian planning can be
grouped into a few big dreams:
1. Economic Growth
• The foremost goal was to increase national income and raise the standard of living.
• India wanted to move from a stagnant, colonial economy to a dynamic, self-reliant
one.
• Growth was seen as the engine that would pull people out of poverty.
2. Self-Reliance
• India had been dependent on Britain for imports during colonial times.
Easy2Siksha.com
• The Plans aimed to reduce dependence on foreign aid and imports, especially in food
and industrial goods.
• Building heavy industries, dams, and infrastructure was part of this dream.
3. Employment Generation
• With millions unemployed or underemployed, creating jobs was a central objective.
• Plans emphasized labour-intensive industries, agriculture, and later, rural
employment schemes.
4. Reduction of Poverty and Inequality
• Economic growth alone was not enough; it had to be inclusive.
• Plans aimed to reduce poverty, bridge the gap between rich and poor, and ensure
social justice.
• Land reforms, subsidies, and welfare schemes were introduced with this aim.
5. Modernization of Agriculture
• Agriculture was the backbone of India, but it was backward and dependent on
monsoons.
• Plans focused on irrigation, fertilizers, high-yield seeds, and mechanization.
• The Green Revolution was a direct outcome of this objective.
6. Industrialization
• Inspired by the Soviet model, India emphasized heavy industries and public sector
enterprises.
• The Second Five-Year Plan (Mahalanobis model) gave priority to steel, power, and
machine-building.
• The idea was that a strong industrial base would make India self-reliant.
7. Balanced Regional Development
• India is diverse, and some regions were more developed than others.
• Plans aimed to spread industries and infrastructure to backward areas.
• Steel plants in Bhilai, Rourkela, and Durgapur were set up in less-developed regions.
8. Social Objectives
• Beyond economics, the Plans aimed at improving education, healthcare, and
nutrition.
• Promoting equality for women, uplifting Scheduled Castes and Tribes, and ensuring
social justice were part of the vision.
9. Environmental Sustainability (later years)
• In the early Plans, environment was not a priority.
Easy2Siksha.com
• But from the 1980s onwards, sustainable development became an objective.
• The Twelfth Plan (2012–17) explicitly spoke of “faster, sustainable, and inclusive
growth.”
How Far Have We Achieved These Objectives?
Now comes the honest part of the story: how much of these dreams have we actually
fulfilled?
1. Economic Growth: Partial Success
• India’s GDP has grown significantly since 1951. From a poor, agrarian economy, India
is now the world’s fifth-largest economy.
• Growth rates improved especially after the 1991 reforms.
• However, growth has been uneven—urban areas surged ahead while rural areas
often lagged.
Achievement: Strong growth, but not equally shared.
2. Self-Reliance: Mixed Results
• In food, India achieved self-sufficiency thanks to the Green Revolution. Famines are
now history.
• In industry, India built a strong base in steel, power, and engineering.
• But dependence on imports remains high in areas like crude oil, electronics, and
defense equipment.
Achievement: Self-reliant in some sectors, dependent in others.
3. Employment Generation: Limited Success
• Public sector enterprises, agriculture, and later IT created jobs.
• Rural employment schemes like MGNREGA provided relief.
• Yet, unemployment and underemployment remain serious issues, especially for
youth.
Achievement: Jobs created, but not enough for the growing population.
4. Poverty Reduction: Significant but Incomplete
• In 1951, more than 50% of Indians lived below the poverty line. Today, that number
has fallen to around 20%.
• Welfare schemes, subsidies, and growth helped reduce poverty.
• But inequality has widened—while some Indians enjoy global lifestyles, many still
struggle for basics.
Achievement: Poverty reduced, inequality increased.
Easy2Siksha.com
5. Agricultural Modernization: Success with Challenges
• The Green Revolution transformed India into a food-surplus nation.
• Irrigation, fertilizers, and HYV seeds boosted productivity.
• But problems remain: farmer indebtedness, regional imbalances, and overuse of
chemicals harming soil and water.
Achievement: Food security achieved, sustainability still a concern.
6. Industrialization: Strong Base, Slow Pace
• India built a solid industrial base in steel, power, and engineering.
• IT and services later became global leaders.
• But manufacturing has not grown as fast as expected—India’s “Make in India” dream
is still a work in progress.
Achievement: Base created, but global competitiveness still limited.
7. Balanced Regional Development: Limited Success
• Some backward regions benefited from public sector industries.
• Yet, states like Maharashtra, Gujarat, and Tamil Nadu surged ahead, while Bihar,
Odisha, and the Northeast lagged.
• Regional inequality remains a challenge.
Achievement: Some progress, but imbalance persists.
8. Social Objectives: Progress but Gaps
• Literacy has risen from 18% in 1951 to over 77% today.
• Life expectancy has doubled, infant mortality has fallen.
• Yet, quality of education and healthcare remains uneven, especially in rural areas.
• Gender equality and social justice have improved, but discrimination still exists.
Achievement: Big improvements, but not universal.
9. Environmental Sustainability: Emerging Priority
• In recent years, India has focused on renewable energy, afforestation, and climate
action.
• But industrial pollution, deforestation, and urban congestion remain serious issues.
Achievement: Awareness created, but action still catching up.
Easy2Siksha.com
Conclusion
The story of India’s Plans is like the story of a student who set ambitious goals at the start of
the year. Some goals were achieved brilliantly—like passing in food security and building an
industrial base. Some were achieved partially—like reducing poverty and creating jobs. And
some remain unfinished—like ensuring equality, balanced regional growth, and
environmental sustainability.
The main objectives of Indian Plans were:
• Economic growth
• Self-reliance
• Employment generation
• Poverty reduction
• Agricultural modernization
• Industrialization
• Balanced regional development
• Social justice
• Sustainability
Achievements: India has come a long way from the poverty-stricken economy of 1951 to a
global player today. But the journey is incomplete. Growth has been real, but uneven;
poverty has reduced, but inequality has grown; industries have risen, but jobs lag behind.
“This paper has been carefully prepared for educational purposes. If you notice any mistakes or
have suggestions, feel free to share your feedback.”
